Answer:
Fellowship is surprised.
Explanation:
Fellowship knows Everyman and knows how he is a brave and fearless strong man. They also know the pilgrimage well and think it would not be such a terrible challenge for Everyman. That's because the Fellowship is not afraid of the pilgrimage, they don't think it is something so threatening and so fearful for a strong man like Everyman, for this reason, when they learn of Everyman's suffering they are very surprised.
